MADISON COUNTY, MS (WLBT) - A political feud continued in Madison County Wednesday as some residents questioned the use of their taxpayer dollars for road contracts. Money was pocketed by the county engineer whose firm was given multi-million dollar projects.
According to Madison Mayor Mary Hawkins Butler, private citizens hired engineer Richard McAfee of Florida to review Madison County contracts with Rudy Warnock's engineering firm. McAfee is with PMA Consultants, LLC.
McAfee used public records from nine roadway projects. He claimed to have found multiple instances of excessive fees and two million dollars worth of questionable disbursements to Warnock & Associates, LLC.
"Principally, it appeared to be the result of the inadequate oversight and then some instances of Warnock & Associates potentially over charging or double charging. For the most part it appears to be a combination of the two,"McAfee told WLBT news in an interview Wednesday.
So we posed this question, did supervisors protect the public's interest and taxpayer dollars in their dealings with their county engineer who got lucrative contracts? McAffee said no, but Madison County Administrator Mark Houston defended the elected officials.
"Every payment regarding engineering contracts was contractually legal and correctly documented," said Houston.
"There were inadequate checks and balances," countered McAfee. "There were fees in the contracts that for reimbursement that were far beyond the norm."
Among the examples cited were laptop processors and computers, for which Warnock was reimbursed a rate of 20 dollars per hour for months. "You could buy 41 laptops with that money," said McAfee.
The county also paid Warnock 100 dollars a day for the use of a field truck plus on 35 cents per mile for gas according to the hired consultant.
A charge of $5.00 was paid daily for a mobile phone.
"Is this excessive? $22,102.63 for use of a field truck? Oh yes, you could have bought the truck," said McAfee.
We posed the same question to Houston. "Is that okay?"
His reply, "Well, these hourly rates were debated in open board sessions here."
McAfee shot back, "From the documentation I've got so far, there is no smoking gun just a heck of a lot of smoke."
Houston told us, "It's a policy question of what the best expenditures of taxpayer dollars are." He said most counties use their own county engineer for projects, adding that this saved taxpayer dollars.
The PMA consultant's review stated that Madison County entered into a series of contracts with Warnock and Associates, LLC, beginning in 2005. "Irregularities in the administration of these contracts, on the part of the county and Warnock and Associates, LLC, are the basis for the remainder of this report."
In "Discussion, Issue 1" the report stated, "The lack of proper checks and balances created a situation where the County Engineer designed and approved his own work. The Rules and Regulations of the Mississippi Board of Licensure are binding upon every person holding a certificate of licensure as professional engineer or surveyor and on all partnerships or corporations or other legal entities authorized to offer or perform engineering or surveying services in the State."
Rule 17.0: CODE OF PROFESSIONAL CONDUCT
17.04: Conflict of Interest
7. A licensee serving in any official capacity, either part-time or full-time, as the engineer or surveyor for any county, city or other governmental body, board or agency, where plans or documents must be submitted to him for review, approval or a recommendation for approval, cannot review, approve or recommend approval of his own plans or documents, or plans or documents prepared by any member of the firm of which he is a member.
ISSUE 1 - Of the ten contracts reviewed, Mr. Warnock signed each and every contract between Madison County and Warnock and Associates, LLC, as "Rudy Warnock, PE, Madison County Engineer," and then reviewed and approved the resulting designs. This was because the County did not have another Professional Engineer in a position of responsible charge to provide an independent professional peer assessment.
ISSUE 2 - The contract requirements regarding notification and consultation with the County regarding subcontracts appear not to have been enforced by the County and appear to have been breached by Warnock and Associates, LLC.
ISSUE 3 - The contract requirements regarding reimbursable expenses appear not to have been enforced by the County and appear to have been breached.
ISSUE 4 - The County contracts, rather than incentivize the Engineer to control costs, reward him for construction cost growth.
ISSUE 5 - The County contracts shift significant liability and risk from the Engineer to the County.
ISSUE 6 - The fee rates paid to Warnock and Associates appear to be high.
ISSUE -7 The County appears to have paid Warnock and Associates twice for Utility Permit Oversight, over $36,000 in a 13 month period from October 2006 through November 2007.
SUMMARY IN PART: It would appear that funds in excess of $2 million deserve scrutiny as potentially having been disbursed without adequate control and oversight. A detailed audit would identify disbursements warranting an investigation.
Wednesday, June 19 2013 12:38 PM EDT2013-06-19 16:38:10 GMT
Ridgeland Police are looking for an unidentified woman who tried to use a stolen credit card at a local business. The woman tried to buy over $900 in gift cards and other merchandise.The woman was wearingMore >>
Ridgeland Police are looking for an unidentified woman who tried to use a stolen credit card at a local business. The woman tried to buy over $900 in gift cards and other merchandise.More >>
Wednesday, June 19 2013 7:34 PM EDT2013-06-19 23:34:37 GMT
The Alabama Department of Public Safety has issued a Missing Child Media Alert after a 2-month-old baby was allegedly taken by a 14-year-old girl early Monday morning from Birmingham. Police say 2-month-oldMore >>
Birmingham Police have confirmed that missing infant De'Anthony Kelly and his abductor, Dor'Sayde Gathright were located in Dallas, Texas Tuesday night, and were taken into custody without incident. More >>
Wednesday, June 19 2013 3:53 PM EDT2013-06-19 19:53:05 GMT
Jury selection for the Casey Mark Burgess trial was scheduled to get underway Monday afternoon in Brandon. Thirty-six year-old Burgess is charged with kidnapping and aggravated assault in the attemptedMore >>
Judge John Emfinger has sentenced Casey Mark Burgess to 20 years for aggravated assault and 10 years for attempted kidnapping. A jury found Casey Mark Burgess guilty of those charges Wednesday, in the attempted abduction of a woman in the Castlewoods area in September of 2011.More >>
Tuesday, June 18 2013 7:14 PM EDT2013-06-18 23:14:24 GMT
There's a Toyota Tacoma pickup truck lodged on the east bank of the Pearl River, just below Interstate 20, in Rankin County. It is not clear how the truck got there, or exactly when.The truck was reportedMore >>
There's a Toyota Tacoma pickup truck lodged on the east bank of the Pearl River, just below Interstate 20, in Rankin County. It is not clear how the truck got there, or exactly when.More >>
Wednesday, June 19 2013 12:24 PM EDT2013-06-19 16:24:37 GMT
The Adams County Sheriff's Office is searching for a fugitive on the run. Deputies say two men stole more than $3,000 worth of merchandise from their employer and one of the culprits is still loose.PublicMore >>
The Adams County Sheriff's Office is searching for a fugitive on the run. Deputies say two men stole more than $3,000 worth of merchandise from their employer and one of the culprits is still loose.More >>
Tuesday, June 18 2013 5:42 PM EDT2013-06-18 21:42:49 GMT
Pearl police say they seized several pounds of marijuana after a Florida man was found smoking the drug in a restaurant parking lot. Matthew Leonard, 31, of Gainesville, FL has been charged with the intentMore >>
Pearl police say they seized several pounds of marijuana after a Florida man was caught smoking the drug in a restaurant parking lot.More >>
Tuesday, June 18 2013 7:31 PM EDT2013-06-18 23:31:40 GMT
Ridgeland police officers and Madison County sheriff's deputies have surrounded a house on Bryceland Drive in Ridgeland. Lt. John Neil with the Ridgeland Police Department says a resident called policeMore >>
Ridgeland Chief of Police Jimmy Houston said the standoff in Ridgeland is resolved.More >>
Wednesday, June 19 2013 7:10 PM EDT2013-06-19 23:10:32 GMT
Some Jackson business owners called 3 On Your Side about an intersection that has had more than it's share of traffic accidents. It's located in an area known as 5-points where Bailey Avenue crosses WoodrowMore >>
Some Jackson business owners called 3 On Your Side about an intersection that has had more than it's share of traffic accidents. It's located in an area known as 5-points where Bailey Avenue crosses Woodrow Wilson near the Jackson Medical Mall.More >>
WLBT 3 - Fox 40
715 South Jefferson Street
Jackson, Mississippi 39201